Updated November 2026

Choosing the best potty training for a puppy comes down to matching the product to your home, your puppy’s size, and how you plan to handle accidents. This guide compares six widely available options, from indoor pee pad systems and training trays to attractant sprays and door bells. Each pick was evaluated on research-based criteria: manufacturer specifications, brand reputation, and patterns in owner feedback. We did not test these products ourselves, so treat the notes below as a starting point and check the current listing before you buy.

Our top picks at a glance

  1. 12-Step Potty Training SystemTOP CHOICEBest overall2-Step Potty Training SystemView on Amazon
  2. 2Potty Training Spray for Dogs, Natural Dog Pee SprayTOP CHOICEBest for outdoor-first trainingPotty Training Spray for Dogs, Natural Dog Pee SprayView on Amazon
  3. 3UPIT Puppy Potty Tray with MeshTOP CHOICEBest for small apartmentsUPIT Puppy Potty Tray with MeshView on Amazon
  4. 4COOYOO Dog DoorbellsBest for teaching a signalCOOYOO Dog DoorbellsView on Amazon
  5. 5Dog Grass Pad with TrayBest for reusable indoor setupsDog Grass Pad with TrayView on Amazon
  6. 6NaturVet Potty Here Training Aid SprayBest for a single-product spray fixNaturVet Potty Here Training Aid SprayView on Amazon

Our Top Picks

Quick Comparison

Product Best for Key feature
2-Step Potty Training System Households wanting a full system Plant-based formula with a two-step routine
Dog Grass Pad with Tray Indoor and outdoor reusable potty spots Artificial turf surface, reusable
UPIT Puppy Potty Tray with Mesh Small dogs and small spaces Leak-proof tray with mesh pee pad holder
Potty Training Spray for Dogs, Natural Dog Pee Spray Pee pads, trays, grass and yards Natural attractant spray for multiple surfaces
NaturVet Potty Here Training Aid Spray Owners wanting one trusted spray brand Indoor and outdoor formula, 8 oz bottle
COOYOO Dog Doorbells Puppies learning to signal they need out Adjustable hanging bells for door handles

2-Step Potty Training System

2-Step Potty Training System , Gentle Plant-Based Formula Potty Training Spray for Dogs, Not Here & Here Potty Set, 6.8 fl oz

2-Step Potty Training System , Gentle Plant-Based Formula Potty Training Spray for Dogs, Not Here & Here Potty Set, 6.8 fl oz

View on Amazon

Best for: Owners who want a complete, two-step routine built around one spray and one potty set.

This system suits first-time puppy owners who prefer a clear sequence to follow. The “Not Here” and “Here” naming reflects a common approach: discourage the wrong spots and reinforce the right one.

Key specs

  • Plant-based, gentle formula
  • 6.8 fl oz volume
  • Sold as a potty training set (Not Here and Here components)

Pros

  • Clear two-step structure is easy to follow
  • Plant-based formula is a gentler option for many households
  • Works as a complete routine rather than a single product

Cons

  • Results still depend on consistent schedule and supervision
  • Sprays alone do not replace regular outdoor trips

Bottom line: A strong pick for first-time owners who want a structured program rather than piecing together separate products.

View on Amazon

Dog Grass Pad with Tray

Dog Grass Pad with Tray, 23''X17'' Small Artificial Turf Grass Potty, Reusable Puppy Pee Pads for Dogs, Portable Dog Litter Box for Indoor Outdoor Potty Training Toilet

Dog Grass Pad with Tray, 23''X17'' Small Artificial Turf Grass Potty, Reusable Puppy Pee Pads for Dogs, Portable Dog Litter Box for Indoor Outdoor Potty Training Toilet

View on Amazon

Best for: Indoor and outdoor potty spots that can be reused and moved.

Good for apartments, balconies, or owners who want a grass-style surface indoors. Owners often report that a grass-textured pad helps puppies who prefer soft, natural-feeling ground.

Key specs

  • Listed size: 23 x 17 inches
  • Artificial turf grass surface
  • Reusable with tray design

Pros

  • Reusable, reducing repeat purchases of disposable pads
  • Grass texture may appeal to puppies used to outdoor surfaces
  • Works indoors and outdoors

Cons

  • Requires regular rinsing and drying to avoid odor buildup
  • Larger footprint than a basic tray

Bottom line: Best for owners who want a reusable, grass-style spot and can commit to routine cleaning.

View on Amazon

UPIT Puppy Potty Tray with Mesh

UPIT Puppy Potty Tray with Mesh – Dog Pee Pad Holder for Small Dogs & Puppies, Indoor Dog Potty Training Toilet, Plastic Leak-Proof Dog Potty Tray (Small - 20 x 16 in)

UPIT Puppy Potty Tray with Mesh – Dog Pee Pad Holder for Small Dogs & Puppies, Indoor Dog Potty Training Toilet, Plastic Leak-Proof Dog Potty Tray (Small – 20 x 16 in)

View on Amazon

Best for: Small dogs and compact indoor spaces where a pee pad needs to stay in place.

A small-format tray suits small breeds and puppies still learning to aim. The mesh holder keeps pads from sliding around, which helps reduce messes on the floor.

Key specs

  • Listed size: 20 x 16 inches (small)
  • Plastic, leak-proof tray base
  • Mesh holder for pee pads

Pros

  • Mesh holder keeps pads from shifting
  • Compact size fits apartments and kitchens
  • Leak-proof base protects flooring

Cons

  • Too small for larger breeds as they grow
  • Pads must be replaced regularly

Bottom line: A practical choice for small puppies and tight indoor spaces.

View on Amazon

Potty Training Spray for Dogs, Natural Dog Pee Spray

Potty Training Spray for Dogs, Natural Dog Pee Spray, Go Here Dog Potty Attractant Spray, Puppy Potty Training Spray for Pee Pads, Trays, Grass, Indoor & Outdoor Housebreaking Aid

Potty Training Spray for Dogs, Natural Dog Pee Spray, Go Here Dog Potty Attractant Spray, Puppy Potty Training Spray for Pee Pads, Trays, Grass, Indoor & Outdoor Housebreaking Aid

View on Amazon

Best for: Households training on pee pads, trays, grass, or both indoors and outdoors.

Attractant sprays are meant to draw a puppy back to a designated spot by scent. This option is marketed for use across several surfaces, which suits owners switching between indoor and outdoor areas.

Key specs

  • Natural formula, marketed as a dog pee attractant
  • Suitable for pads, trays, and grass
  • Indoor and outdoor use

Pros

  • Works across multiple surface types
  • Natural formulation appeals to owners avoiding harsh chemicals
  • Useful for marking a spot after a successful trip

Cons

  • Spray results vary and do not replace consistent scheduling
  • Should be applied only to designated spots, not furniture

Bottom line: Good for owners who need one spray that works across several surfaces.

View on Amazon

NaturVet Potty Here Training Aid Spray

Train Puppies & Dogs Where to Potty, Formulated for Indoor & Outdoor Use NaturVet Potty Here Training Aid Spray for Puppies and Dogs - 8 oz

Train Puppies & Dogs Where to Potty, Formulated for Indoor & Outdoor Use NaturVet Potty Here Training Aid Spray for Puppies and Dogs – 8 oz

View on Amazon

Best for: Owners who prefer a well-known brand and a single spray for indoor and outdoor use.

NaturVet is a long-established pet wellness brand, and this spray is positioned as a simple training aid. It suits owners who want one product for both indoor and outdoor spots.

Key specs

  • 8 oz bottle
  • Formulated for indoor and outdoor use
  • Designed for puppies and adult dogs

Pros

  • Established brand with a broad product line
  • Single product covers indoor and outdoor use
  • Larger bottle size for repeated applications

Cons

  • Spray alone will not teach bladder control
  • Strong scent may not suit every household

Bottom line: A solid, familiar option for owners who want a single brand-backed spray.

View on Amazon

COOYOO Dog Doorbells

COOYOO Dog Doorbells, Adjustable Potty Training Dog Bells, Upgraded for Training Your Puppy The Easy Way, Premium Quality Housetraining Hanging Bell-5 Extra Large Loud 1.5 DoorBells

COOYOO Dog Doorbells, Adjustable Potty Training Dog Bells, Upgraded for Training Your Puppy The Easy Way, Premium Quality Housetraining Hanging Bell-5 Extra Large Loud 1.5 DoorBells

View on Amazon

Best for: Teaching puppies to signal they need to go outside by ringing a bell.

Door bells work best alongside consistent outdoor trips. Hang the bells at a height your puppy can reach, and ring them with the puppy each time you head out.

Key specs

  • Adjustable hanging bells
  • Designed for door handles
  • Five-bell set, marketed as extra loud

Pros

  • Teaches a clear communication signal
  • Adjustable length suits different door heights
  • Inexpensive way to add a signal to training

Cons

  • Puppies may ring them for attention rather than needing to go
  • Requires frequent reinforcement to stay effective

Bottom line: A useful add-on for owners who want their puppy to signal a bathroom need at the door.

View on Amazon

Buying Guide

Puppy size and breed

Size determines whether a tray, a pad holder, or a larger grass pad will fit comfortably. Small breeds often do well with compact trays, while larger puppies need more floor space to turn around and squat. Check your puppy’s expected adult size, not just current weight, before buying anything that will be outgrown quickly.

Good picks for this: UPIT Puppy Potty Tray with Mesh, Dog Grass Pad with Tray

Indoor versus outdoor training

Decide where the main potty spot will be. Indoor-only setups, such as pads and trays, suit apartments and bad-weather months. Outdoor training works best when you can take the puppy out on a schedule, usually after waking, after meals, and after play. Many owners combine both during the first few months.

Good picks for this: Dog Grass Pad with Tray, Potty Training Spray for Dogs, Natural Dog Pee Spray

Attractant spray compatibility

Check the label for which surfaces the spray is intended for. Some are made for pads and grass, others for trays or hard floors. Apply only to the designated spot, and avoid over-soaking, which can make a surface smell strongly and attract repeat accidents in the wrong place.

Good picks for this: 2-Step Potty Training System, NaturVet Potty Here Training Aid Spray

Ease of cleaning

Reusable products save money over time but require rinsing and drying. Disposable pads are simpler but need more frequent replacement. A leak-proof tray with a removable holder can make cleanup faster. Plan a cleaning routine before you start, not after the first accident.

Good picks for this: UPIT Puppy Potty Tray with Mesh, Dog Grass Pad with Tray

Durability and materials

Plastic trays should be sturdy enough that a puppy cannot chew through the edges, and mesh holders should stay secure under pressure. Check whether a grass pad’s backing is reinforced. Replace any product with cracks, torn surfaces, or persistent odor, since these can harbor bacteria.

Good picks for this: UPIT Puppy Potty Tray with Mesh, Dog Grass Pad with Tray

Signaling tools

Door bells are a common addition once a puppy begins to associate going outside with a routine. Mount them at a height the puppy can reach, pair each ring with an outdoor trip, and reward success right away. They work best as a supplement, not a substitute, for supervision and scheduled breaks.

Good picks for this: COOYOO Dog Doorbells

Your training schedule and supervision

No product replaces a schedule. Most puppies need to go out roughly every one to two hours during the day, plus after waking, eating, and playing. Consistent supervision, crate or pen use when you cannot watch, and calm praise after success matter more than any single item on this list.

Good picks for this: 2-Step Potty Training System, COOYOO Dog Doorbells

FAQ

How long does potty training a puppy usually take?

Many puppies become reliable within a few months, but timelines vary by breed, age, and consistency. Smaller breeds sometimes take longer because their bladders are smaller. Expect setbacks, and do not punish accidents, since this can make a puppy hide when it needs to go.

Should I use pee pads or take my puppy outside?

Outdoor training usually produces faster long-term results because it teaches the puppy that the right spot is outside. Pee pads can help in apartments or during bad weather, but switching from pads to outdoors later can be harder. Many owners choose one main method and stay consistent.

Do attractant sprays actually work?

Sprays can help a puppy recognize a designated spot by scent, but they work best alongside a schedule and rewards. Owners often report better results when they apply a small amount to a clean spot and avoid overusing it. Results vary, and a spray is a support tool, not a complete training method.

How often should I take a puppy out?

A common guideline is to take a puppy out after waking, after meals, after play, and every one to two hours during the day. Very young puppies need more frequent trips. Adjust based on how your puppy behaves, and watch for sniffing, circling, or restlessness.

What should I do after an accident?

Clean the spot with an enzymatic cleaner so the odor does not draw the puppy back. Avoid harsh ammonia-based products, which can smell like urine to a dog. Do not scold the puppy. Redirect calmly to the right spot if you catch it in progress.

When should I talk to a veterinarian about potty problems?

If a puppy suddenly has accidents after being reliable, strains to urinate, shows blood in urine, or drinks and urinates much more than usual, contact a veterinarian. These signs can point to a urinary tract infection or another health issue, and a professional should check them.

Conclusion

The best potty training for a puppy depends on your living situation and routine. A structured system like the 2-Step Potty Training System suits first-time owners who want a clear plan. A compact tray works for small dogs in tight spaces, while a grass pad fits owners who want a reusable indoor spot. Attractant sprays and door bells add support but work best alongside consistent outdoor trips and calm reinforcement. Pick the option that fits your home, and give your puppy time and steady routine.

Sources

Miles Sinclair

About Miles Sinclair

Miles Sinclair is part of our editorial team and reviews and edits our toddler development & behavior guides, checking product details against manufacturer specifications and owner feedback.